Everyone said the foreclosed farm was empty, but they were wrong; something vicious remained, guarding a scarecrow wearing a dead woman’s dress.
Part 1: The Beast of the Cornfield
Sarah Jenkins hated foreclosures. The silence always felt heavy, like the held breath of a family that had lost everything they owned. She parked her company sedan on the cracked gravel driveway of the Thorne property, the tires crunching loudly in the oppressive stillness. The November sky hung low and grey over acres of dead, unharvested corn stalks that rattled like dry bones in the cold wind.
Her job was supposed to be simple today. She needed to document the abandonment, snap a few photos for the bank file, and authorize the bulldozers for next week. The property was slated to become a new housing development by spring. Sarah grabbed her digital camera and stepped out into the chill, pulling her coat tighter around her.
The air smelled intensely of wet earth and decay. She walked past the empty, sagging farmhouse, its windows boarded up like closed eyes. About fifty yards into the sprawling field, something bright caught her eye against the overwhelming brown landscape. It was a scarecrow, tethered precariously to a rotting wooden post.
It wasn’t wearing typical farmer’s overalls. It was draped in a faded, floral print dress that seemed wildly out of place, billowing strangely in the breeze. Sarah frowned, raising her camera to zoom in on the bizarre sight. It looked uncomfortably human from this distance, like a forgotten person left to weather the coming winter alone.
She took a cautious step forward, the dry corn husks brushing against her denim jeans. That’s when the silence shattered completely. A low, guttural growl erupted from the base of the scarecrow, vibrating through the frozen ground beneath her feet. It wasn’t a warning bark; it was a predatory sound.
Before Sarah could react, a massive shape launched itself from the shadows beneath the tattered dress. It was enormous, a whirlwind of matted, mud-caked fur and bared yellow teeth. It roared like a wild thing defending its den, closing the distance between them in terrifying leaps. Sarah shrieked, stumbling backward and dropping her camera in blind panic.
She fell hard onto the frozen dirt, throwing her arms up to protect her face. The beast was on her in seconds, hot, foul breath hitting her skin as she braced for the tear of flesh. But the bite never came. The creature froze inches from her throat, its single visible eye wild with terror rather than aggression.
A sudden gust of wind whipped the scarecrow’s dress violently to the side, making the straw figure lurch. The beast immediately abandoned Sarah, scrambling backward to interpose its massive body between the wind and the straw figure. It whined pitifully, nudging the hem of the soiled dress with its nose, as if trying to comfort it.
Sarah didn’t waste the opportunity; she scrambled to her feet and bolted for the safety of her car, locking the doors with shaking hands. Safe inside, breathing hard, she grabbed her binoculars to look back at the scene. The vicious beast was gone. In its place was a heartbroken, ruined creature, curled up tightly against the scarecrow’s wooden leg, resting its heavy head on the straw “lap” of the figure. Sarah realized with a chilling jolt that the dog wasn’t guarding the property from intruders. It was protecting the scarecrow from the world, and she needed to know why.
Part 2: The Death Sentence
The silence of the farm didn’t last long. Within an hour, the gravel driveway was crowded with two county sheriff cruisers and an Animal Control van. The red and blue emergency lights sliced through the gray afternoon gloom, casting frantic shadows against the side of the weathered barn.
Sarah stood by the hood of her car, arms crossed tightly against her chest. She watched as Officer Miller, a man with a thick gray mustache and tired eyes, adjusted his belt. He looked out toward the cornfield where the scarecrow stood. Even from here, they could hear the low, rumbling growl of the beast.
“That’s a big dog to be out here on his own,” Miller said, spitting on the frozen ground. “Bank says the property is vacant. If he’s aggressive, we can’t have him roaming. Kids cut through these fields to get to the creek.”
Two Animal Control officers, clad in thick protective gear, pulled long catch-poles from the back of their van. They looked like they were preparing for war rather than a rescue. The sight of the metal nooses made Sarah’s stomach turn.
“He didn’t bite me,” Sarah said quickly, surprising herself. “He stopped. He just wanted me to stay away from the scarecrow.”
Miller looked at her, his expression grim. “He charged you, Miss Jenkins. That’s intent. If he attacks the boys when they go in, I have to put him down. Those are the rules.”
The group began to march into the field. Sarah followed at a distance, her heart hammering against her ribs. The cornstalks whipped against their legs. As they encroached on the thirty-yard radius of the scarecrow, the dog emerged again.
This time, the beast didn’t hide. He stood directly in front of the scarecrow, his legs braced wide in the mud. He was a terrifying sight, a wall of matted grey and white fur. His single good eye locked onto the catch-poles, and he let out a bark that shook the air.
“Easy now,” one of the catchers shouted, advancing slowly. The dog lunged, snapping his jaws inches from the pole. The metal clattered against his teeth.
“Back off!” Miller shouted, his hand hovering near his holster. “He’s rabid!”
“No!” Sarah screamed, rushing forward past the officer. “Look at him! Look at what he’s doing!”
The dog hadn’t advanced to kill. Every time the men stepped back, the dog retreated instantly to the scarecrow. He pressed his flank against the wooden post, trembling violently. He wasn’t guarding territory; he was acting as a living shield.
The dog looked at Sarah. For a split second, the aggression in his eye vanished, replaced by a desperate, pleading terror. He let out a high-pitched whine that sounded like a crying child, then nudged the hem of the floral dress with his nose.
“He’s protecting it,” Sarah whispered, her voice trembling. “He thinks the scarecrow is a person.”
Miller paused, his hand dropping from his weapon. He squinted at the scene. The wind picked up, blowing the dress around, and the dog immediately turned to shield the straw figure from the gust.
“I’ll give you forty-eight hours,” Miller grunted, signaling the Animal Control team to lower their poles. “But if that dog is still here when the bulldozers arrive on Monday, we handle it my way. And my way isn’t pretty.”
Sarah watched them walk away. She was left alone with the beast and the scarecrow. She had bought him time, but she had no idea how to save a creature that would rather die than abandon a pile of straw.
Part 3: The Secret of the Floral Dress
Sarah drove back to town, her mind racing. She needed to understand what she was dealing with. The connection between the animal and that specific scarecrow was too profound to be random. She pulled into the parking lot of the county clerk’s office, hoping to find records of the previous owners.
The clerk, a chatty woman named Brenda with bright red glasses, sighed when Sarah mentioned the Thorne property. “Sad business, that,” Brenda said, tapping on her keyboard. “Elias Thorne. He lived there for fifty years. Lost the place about three months ago.”
“Did he have a dog?” Sarah asked.
“Oh, sure. Barnaby. A big Old English Sheepdog. That dog went everywhere with them,” Brenda replied, looking over her spectacles. “But it wasn’t just Elias. It was his wife, Martha. That farm was their whole world.”
Sarah leaned in. “What happened to Martha?”
“Cancer. Took her about two years ago,” Brenda’s voice dropped to a whisper. “Elias spent every dime he had on her treatments. Re-mortgaged the farm, sold the tractors. He tried to save her, but the bills just swallowed him whole. After she passed, Elias… well, he started losing his grip on reality a bit.”
Sarah thanked her and drove to the only diner in town, looking for anyone who knew the Thornes personally. She found an elderly man named George nursing a black coffee. He had been Elias’s neighbor before selling his own land to the developers last year.
“The dress?” George chuckled sadly when Sarah described the scarecrow. He stared into his coffee cup, his eyes glazing over with memory. “I know that dress. Martha wore it to the county fair every year back in the seventies. It was her favorite. She said the flowers made the corn grow better.”
George looked up, his face lined with grief. “When Martha got sick, she couldn’t go out to the fields anymore. Barnaby—that’s the dog—used to sit by her wheelchair on the porch for hours. He wouldn’t chase rabbits, wouldn’t eat unless she told him to. He was her guardian.”
“So why is the dress on a scarecrow?” Sarah asked.
“Elias put it there,” George said, his voice cracking. “After Martha died, Elias started forgetting things. But he remembered how much she loved looking at the corn. He put her dress on that scarecrow so he could look out the window and pretend she was still standing there, watching the harvest. It was his way of keeping her alive.”
Sarah felt a chill run down her spine. “And the dog?”
“Barnaby never understood she was gone,” George shook his head slowly. “He thinks that scarecrow is her. He thinks she’s just standing very still. If you try to move him, you’re trying to take him away from his mother. And that dog will die before he lets that happen.”
Sarah left the diner with a heavy heart. The dog wasn’t crazy. He was the most loyal soul in the entire state, guarding a ghost made of straw and polyester.
Part 4: The Refused Meal
The sun was setting by the time Sarah returned to the farm. The temperature had dropped, and the wind was biting. She had stopped at a grocery store and bought two pounds of high-quality ground beef and a jug of water. Barnaby had to be starving.
She parked the car and walked slowly toward the field. The scarecrow was a lonely silhouette against the purple sky. Barnaby was lying curled around the base of the post, his fur blending in with the dead stalks.
“Hey, Barnaby,” she called out softly. The dog lifted his head. He didn’t growl this time, but his body tensed. He watched her every move.
Sarah placed the plastic bowl of meat on the ground about twenty feet away from him. The smell of the fresh beef wafted through the air. She saw Barnaby’s nose twitch. He licked his chops, and his stomach let out a growl loud enough to hear.
“It’s okay, boy. Come get it,” she coaxed, stepping back to give him space.
Barnaby stood up. His legs were shaking from exhaustion and hunger. He took one step toward the food, then stopped. He looked back at the scarecrow. The wind rustled the dress, making the empty sleeve wave. Barnaby immediately sat back down, pressing his body against the post. He wouldn’t leave her. Not even for a second.
“You’re going to starve to death,” Sarah whispered, tears pricking her eyes.
Suddenly, the quiet was broken by the sound of a loud engine and raucous laughter. A beat-up pickup truck swerved into the driveway, tires spinning in the gravel. Three teenagers hopped out, holding smartphones and flashlights.
“Yo! There it is!” one of them shouted, pointing a phone camera at the field. “The Ghost Dog of Oakhaven! Let’s get a reaction shot for the stream!”
Sarah ran toward them. “Get out of here! This is private property!”
The kids ignored her. One of them, a boy in a varsity jacket, picked up a large clod of frozen dirt and hurled it toward the scarecrow. “Wake up, Cujo!”
The dirt clod hit the scarecrow’s wooden shoulder with a loud thud. Barnaby erupted. He didn’t just bark; he screamed—a sound of pure outrage. He threw himself in front of the scarecrow, snapping at the air, daring them to come closer.
Another kid threw a stone. It struck Barnaby on the flank. The dog yelped but didn’t retreat. He stood his ground, taking the hit to protect the dress.
“Stop it!” Sarah screamed, grabbing the arm of the kid preparing to throw again. She wasn’t a confrontational person, but a fire ignited in her chest. “He is protecting his family! Get out before I call the cops and have you arrested for trespassing and animal cruelty!”
The teenagers, startled by her ferocity, lowered their phones. “Jeez, lady. It’s just a dumb mutt,” the leader muttered, but they backed away.
As the truck sped off, Sarah turned back to the field. Barnaby was checking the scarecrow, sniffing the hem of the dress to make sure “she” wasn’t hurt. He looked at Sarah, and for the first time, his tail gave a tiny, almost imperceptible wag. He understood she had defended them.
Part 5: The Forgotten Man
Saturday morning brought a cold drizzle. Sarah knew she had to find the only person Barnaby might listen to. She drove to the “Shady Oaks Care Center,” a state-funded nursing home on the edge of the county. The building smelled of bleach and boiled vegetables.
She found Elias Thorne in a shared room at the end of a long, fluorescent-lit hallway. He was sitting in a wheelchair by the window, staring out at the parking lot. He looked frail, his skin like crumpled paper.
“Mr. Thorne?” Sarah asked gently.
He turned slowly. His eyes were cloudy. “Martha? Is the corn ready?”
“No, Mr. Thorne. I’m Sarah. I’m here to talk about Barnaby.”
The name acted like a key unlocking a rusty door. Elias’s back straightened. A spark of clarity returned to his eyes. “Barnaby? My boy? Is he… is he waiting in the truck?”
Sarah pulled a chair close. “Mr. Thorne, Barnaby is still at the farm. He’s guarding the scarecrow. He won’t let anyone near it. He thinks it’s Martha.”
Elias’s face crumpled. He covered his face with his trembling hands, and his shoulders shook with silent sobs. “I know,” he whispered. “I know he does.”
“Why didn’t you take him?” Sarah asked softly.
“They came for me in the morning,” Elias said, his voice thick with regret. ” The sheriff. The bank men. They said I couldn’t keep the house. I had nowhere to go. This place… they don’t allow dogs. Not big ones.”
He looked up at Sarah, tears streaming down his cheeks. “I couldn’t explain it to him. How do you tell a dog you’ve failed him? So, I put Martha’s dress on the scarecrow. I told him, ‘Watch her, Barnaby. Watch her until I come back.’ I lied to him.”
The confession hung heavy in the air. “I lied so he wouldn’t chase the ambulance,” Elias sobbed. “I gave him a job so he wouldn’t die of a broken heart when I left. But now… now I’ve condemned him to wait for a ghost that’s never coming home.”
Sarah took his hand. It was cold and rough. “We can save him, Elias. But I need your help. He’s starving. He won’t leave the scarecrow because he promised you he’d protect her.”
Elias reached into his shirt pocket and pulled out a small, worn dog whistle. “I can’t walk,” he said. “But he knows this sound. It’s our dinner call. If you blow this… he might trust you. Tell him… tell him ‘Good boy, Barnaby. Mission accomplished.’ That’s the release command.”
Sarah took the silver whistle. It felt heavy, burdened with the weight of a broken promise. She had the tool to save the dog, but using it meant breaking Barnaby’s heart with the truth: that his watch was over, and no one was coming back.
Part 6: Storm of Greed
The timeline was collapsing. On Saturday afternoon, Sarah received a curt email from her regional manager at GreenField Assets. The subject line was simply: “SITE CLEARANCE – URGENT.”
The message was brief and cold. “Client (Horizon Development) reports weather delays expected next week. They are moving the demolition schedule up to Sunday morning at 07:00. The property must be clear of all biological hazards. If Animal Control cannot secure the animal, private contractors will be authorized to remove the threat.”
“Private contractors” was corporate code for exterminators with rifles.
Sarah looked at the weather radar on her phone. A massive low-pressure system was barreling across the Midwest. The weathermen were calling it a “winter hurricane”—freezing rain, sixty-mile-per-hour winds, and plummeting temperatures. It was set to make landfall tonight.
She felt helpless. She couldn’t move Barnaby. The dog was dug in like a tick. If she tried to drag him away, he would fight her, and if he fought, he would be labeled dangerous and killed.
Desperate, Sarah opened her laptop. She didn’t have money or authority, but she had the photos she had taken on the first day. She uploaded the image of Barnaby—the terrifying, mud-caked beast—curled up gently with his head resting on the scarecrow’s lap.
She titled the post: ” The Guardian of the Cornfield.”
She wrote everything. She wrote about the foreclosure, about Elias in the nursing home, about the lie that kept the dog waiting, and about the corporation coming to bulldoze the only family this dog had left. She didn’t name the bank, but she painted a picture of a system that discarded old men and loyal dogs with equal indifference.
“He isn’t guarding a farm,” she typed. “He is guarding a memory. And tonight, a storm is coming that might kill him, followed by bulldozers that definitely will. We need help.”
She hit post.
For an hour, nothing happened. Sarah paced her motel room, watching the rain start to streak against the window. Then, her phone buzzed. Then it buzzed again. Within twenty minutes, it was vibrating continuously.
The story had struck a nerve in the American psyche. Comments poured in from everywhere—farmers in Nebraska, nurses in New York, veterans in Texas. They saw their own struggles in Elias and their own dogs in Barnaby. The debate raged in the comments section. Some called for a rescue mission; others argued that leaving the dog there was cruel. But everyone agreed on one thing: The bulldozers had to wait.
But viral fame doesn’t stop the weather. Outside, the sky turned a bruised purple. The trees began to bend. The storm wasn’t waiting for likes or shares. It was here.
Part 7: The Fateful Night
At 10:00 PM, the power in the motel went out. The wind howled like a freight train, rattling the window frames. Sarah lay in the dark, staring at the ceiling. She couldn’t stop thinking about the farm.
The scarecrow was just wood and straw. In winds like this, it didn’t stand a chance. And when it fell, what would Barnaby do? Would he chase it into the dark? Would he let the wind bury him?
“I can’t let him die alone,” Sarah whispered to the empty room.
She grabbed her keys and the heavy flashlight. The drive to the farm was a nightmare. Rain lashed the windshield in horizontal sheets, rendering her wipers useless. Debris—tree branches, shingles, trash—littered the county road. Her sedan hydroplaned twice, her knuckles white on the steering wheel.
When she turned onto the gravel driveway of the Thorne property, her headlights cut through the deluge to reveal a scene of devastation. The old barn’s roof had partially collapsed. The cornfield was flattened, the stalks beaten into the mud.
But the scarecrow was still standing. Barely.
It was leaning at a forty-five-degree angle. The floral dress was whipping violently, tearing at the seams. And there was Barnaby.
He wasn’t curled up anymore. He was standing on his hind legs, his front paws pressed against the wooden post, pushing back against the wind. He was trying to hold her up.
Sarah gasped, jumping out of the car. The wind nearly knocked her over. “Barnaby!” she screamed, but her voice was swallowed by the gale.
The dog was exhausted. He was slipping in the mud, his coat soaked through, shivering so hard it looked like a seizure. But he wouldn’t let go. He was using his own body weight as an anchor, acting as a living counterweight to keep his “mother” from falling into the mud.
Sarah fought her way through the field, sinking calf-deep in the freezing slush. She reached the dog and grabbed his collar. “Barnaby, stop! It’s okay! You have to let go!”
He turned his head toward her, his single eye wide and bloodshot. He didn’t snap. He looked at her with a profound, crushing sadness. He couldn’t let go. If he let go, she would fall. And if she fell, she was gone.
Part 8: The Shattering
The wind shrieked, a gust stronger than any before it.
CRACK.
The sound was like a gunshot. The wooden post snapped at the base. Sarah threw herself backward as the scarecrow toppled.
Barnaby let out a sound Sarah would never forget—a human scream of grief. As the straw figure hit the muddy ground, the dog threw himself over it. He desperately tried to grab the fabric of the dress with his teeth, pulling at it, trying to drag the sodden mess back up.
“Get up, Martha! Get up!” his actions seemed to scream.
But the scarecrow was dead weight, rapidly disintegrating in the rain and mud. The dress was tearing apart. Barnaby was frantic, pawing at the mud, trying to clean her, trying to save her.
“Barnaby, no!” Sarah lunged forward, grabbing him around the chest. He struggled, flailing against her grip, his eyes locked on the pile of straw.
Suddenly, Sarah remembered the whistle in her pocket. Elias’s whistle. The “Mission Accomplished” signal.
She fumbled with freezing fingers, pulled out the silver whistle, and blew it as hard as she could.
The high-pitched tone cut through the roar of the storm.
Barnaby froze. His ears perked up. He looked around wildly, searching for Elias.
“Good boy!” Sarah yelled, tears mixing with the rain on her face. “Good boy, Barnaby! Mission accomplished! She’s okay! We have to go!”
The command, drilled into him for years, short-circuited his panic. The whistle meant the work was done. The whistle meant it was time to go home.
He looked at the muddy scarecrow one last time, gave it a soft lick on the “face,” and then slumped against Sarah. He had nothing left.
Sarah wrapped her arms around the eighty-pound dog and half-carried, half-dragged him toward the only shelter nearby—the rusted hulk of Elias’s old pickup truck, which was missing its wheels and sat on cinder blocks near the barn.
She managed to shove Barnaby into the cab and climbed in after him. The windows were cracked, but it was dry.
Barnaby collapsed on the torn bench seat, shivering violently. Sarah took off her coat and wrapped it around him. She pulled him onto her lap, hugging his wet, smelly, muddy body as tight as she could to share body heat.
“I’ve got you,” she whispered into his matted fur. “I’ve got you.”
For the first time in months, the Guardian slept.
Part 9: Truth in the Straw
Morning broke with a blinding, cold sun. The storm had passed, leaving the world scoured and clean.
Sarah woke up with a stiff neck, Barnaby’s heavy head resting on her knees. He was still asleep, his breathing raspy but steady. Outside, the sound of heavy diesel engines rumbled.
The bulldozers.
Sarah scrambled out of the truck. Three massive yellow machines were idling at the edge of the property. A foreman in a hard hat was talking to Officer Miller.
“Wait!” Sarah yelled, running toward them, her clothes caked in dried mud.
“Miss Jenkins,” Miller nodded, looking impressed that she was still there. “You survived the night.”
“The dog is secure,” Sarah said, breathless. “He’s in the truck. You can’t start yet. I need to… I need to get something.”
She ran back to the cornfield. The scarecrow was a ruin. The straw was scattered, and the post was splintered. But the dress—the sodden, muddy floral dress—was still there.
Sarah knelt in the mud. She wanted to salvage the dress for Elias. It was the only thing he had left of Martha.
As she carefully unbuttoned the dress from the broken wooden crossbar, her fingers brushed against something hard inside the chest area of the scarecrow. It wasn’t straw.
She frowned and reached inside the lining. Elias had sewn a pocket into the interior of the dress, right where the heart would be. Inside the pocket was a sealed, waterproof metal canister.
Sarah wiped the mud off the lid. Engraved on the metal were the words: Martha Thorne. Beloved Wife. 1948 – 2023.
Sarah sat back on her heels, covering her mouth as the realization hit her like a physical blow.
It wasn’t just a trick. Elias hadn’t just put the dress there to fool the dog. He had hidden Martha’s ashes inside the scarecrow. He couldn’t afford a plot in the cemetery, or perhaps he couldn’t bear to put her in the ground away from the land she loved.
Barnaby hadn’t been guarding a piece of clothing. He had been guarding her. He had known all along. Dogs can smell organic material; they can smell bone and ash. He knew his mistress was inside that straw.
“Oh, Barnaby,” Sarah wept, clutching the canister to her chest. “You good, good boy.”
Part 10: Home is Where the Heart Is
The story of the ashes changed everything.
When Sarah posted the update—a picture of the metal canister held in her muddy hands against the backdrop of the sunrise—the viral spark turned into an inferno. The “Scarecrow Guardian” was no longer just a dog story; it was a story about the sanctity of love and the failure of the system.
Horizon Development, facing a PR nightmare of epic proportions, announced they would pause construction to allow for a “respectful transition.” A GoFundMe page set up by a stranger for Elias hit $50,000 in three hours, then $100,000. People wanted to buy the farm back.
But life isn’t a fairy tale. The farm was too far gone, and Elias was too sick to live on his own. The money couldn’t buy back the past, but it could buy dignity.
Two weeks later.
The Shady Oaks Care Center had a strict “No Pets” policy. But when the Mayor, the local news crew, and thousands of online supporters are watching, policies have a way of bending.
Sarah walked down the hallway. She looked different—softer, less corporate. By her side, on a brand new red leash, walked Barnaby.
He had been bathed, groomed, and fed. His coat was fluffy and white again, his eyes bright. But around his neck, tied like a bandana, was a square of clean, floral fabric cut from Martha’s dress.
They reached Room 3B.
Elias was sitting in his chair. He looked smaller than Sarah remembered. He was staring at his hands, lost in the fog of dementia.
“Elias?” Sarah said softly.
The old man didn’t look up.
Sarah unclipped the leash. “Go say hi, Barnaby.”
Barnaby didn’t need to be told. He trotted across the linoleum floor, his claws clicking softly. He didn’t jump up. He didn’t bark.
He approached the wheelchair and gently, ever so gently, placed his large, fluffy head on Elias’s lap. He let out a long, deep sigh—the sound of a traveler finally dropping their heavy pack.
Elias froze. His trembling hand hovered in the air for a moment, then slowly descended to bury itself in the thick fur.
“Barnaby?” Elias whispered, his voice cracking. “You came back.”
Barnaby closed his eyes. He wasn’t guarding anymore. He was home.
Sarah watched from the doorway, tears streaming down her face. She knew what she had to do. She had already filed the paperwork. Elias couldn’t keep him here, but Sarah could. She would bring Barnaby to visit every single day. She would be the guardian of the guardian.
As she turned to leave them to their moment, she looked at the new phone she had bought. The comments were still rolling in, but one stood out.
“We lose so much in this life—houses, land, money. But looking at that dog, I realize we only really lose something when we stop loving it.”
Sarah smiled, wiped her eyes, and walked out into the bright winter sun, ready to start her new life.
THE END.
Thank you so much for reading this story!
I’d really love to hear your comments and thoughts about this story — your feedback is truly valuable and helps us a lot.
Please leave a comment and share this Facebook post to support the author. Every reaction and review makes a big difference!
This story is a work of fiction created for entertainment and inspirational purposes. While it may draw on real-world themes, all characters, names, and events are imagined. Any resemblance to actual people or situations is purely coincidenta